Category: Latest

Scudamore: The Premier League States Its (Lack Of) Intent

I wrote in my previous article that the Premier League (EPL) statement on its “investigation” into what is beginning to be called “Scudgate” (sigh) posed more questions than answers. The following is what I meant (with the statement in bold): Summary of a meeting of Premier League Clubs held on 19 May 2014. In the matter of media allegations regarding the Chief Executive. This article will take a while. I haven’t even got to the statement itself and already there’s questions. It was reported throughout last week that the EPL’s “Audit and Remuneration (A&R) Committee”, the body which has authorised Scudamore’s salary and bonuses down the years, was to discuss the issue. The BBC website reported on May 16th that they “will meet on Monday to consider disciplinary action against Scudamore.” The Committee’s independence, both professional and personal, from Scudamore was subjected to considerable scrutiny over the weekend. But yesterday (Monday) it was still being reported that the A&R Committee had “emerged” on May 14th as the disciplinary body. Yet the 17 EPL member clubs (relegated and already promoted clubs not included) “emerged” at pretty much the last minute as the actual decision-making body, despite the A&R Committee being reported as part of the EPL’s “due process” for holding Scudamore to account. If you didn’t have complete faith in the good governance of the EPL, you might think they...

Read More

Scudamore : The Story That Won’t Be Brushed Under The Carpet

Dave Boyle enjoyed bits of last week. But, perhaps learning from his experiences in 2011, the rudest word he has come up with in reaction to the “Scudamore affair” is schadenfreudegasm. If Premier League (EPL) Chief Executive Richard Scudamore ever thought the Sunday Mirror newspaper story about his sexist e-mails would end with his apology and the curious inability of the game’s governing body to act against him (the FA, remember), he was wrong. If he thinks the EPL put an end to the affair with their “investigation into the newspaper allegations” and the subsequent statement from acting Chair Peter McCormick, then he’s wrong again. And that’s three “errors of judgment” in a week, which is going some, even for modern “English” football. Scudamore probably thought there were enough vested interests in football – or at least in the money his broadcasting deal negotiating skills have brought to EPL clubs – to protect him. But enough people in and around football resent that money enough to want, and work for, his resignation (what, for instance, have Cardiff City done to deserve £62m?). More importantly, enough people in general simply believe it wrong that Scudamore should remain in his job after admitting to using such discriminatory language. Thus the story stayed sufficiently high-profile to allow it this week’s Sunday Mirror to publish a follow-up. This follow-up was so at odds...

Read More

Alan Dowson: A Manager To Remember

Yes… yes… Murphy’s on about bloody Kingstonian again. But this one’s important. No…really… It may not seem like much of a legacy, I grant you. But when Isthmian League Kingstonian played out a nothing final game of the 2011/12 season, it highlighted just how few such games there had been in manager Alan Dowson’s seven-and-a-bit years at Kingsmeadow, which came to an end last week. Seasoned Ks watchers used to often joke about games having “an end-of-season feel” to them…in mid-September. And it would often be all-too-true.  So for Dowson to virtually eliminate the concept was a huge achievement, alongside the fact that he left Kingstonian – on-field and off – in a demonstrably better state than that in which he found it. Dowson took over a team drifting in the lower-mid reaches of Ryman Division One South and left one which finished second in the Ryman Premier and, if kept together to any significant degree, will surely among the favourites for promotion from it next season. Superficially, that represents solid but unspectacular progress.  However, Dowson, and those he recruited to work with him, did more than that. He re-fashioned and rebuilt a sense of a proper football “club.” This had been lacking for years at Ks, for historical reasons with which I’ll not bore you here, and is something more tangible and important to football at our level....

Read More

Rangers: Split Personalities

For an awkward few days in July 2012 there appeared to be two “Rangers” football clubs on the go. One was what is now called “emerging from administration” – by going into liquidation. And the other was seeking permission to play at Brechin City in the Scottish League Challenge Cup – permission granted by the Scottish Football Association creating an entirely new membership category, specially, and so far solely, for them. There appeared to be two Rangers on the go again last week. One was in court, claiming that their finances were secure and that fans’ threats to withhold season-ticket monies were not a “major concern.” The other was lambasting fans – in a club statement published during the court case – for “creating financial difficulty for Rangers” which could “only damage the club.” Rangers are currently the subject of a covert takeover bid – albeit one hidden in relatively plain sight – by South African-based businessman and lifelong fan, Dave King. King, however, does not want to pay market rate for Rangers, or any rate at all if possible. So he is using fans’ current discontent to deprive Rangers of much-needed season-ticket renewals income, unless or until “fans” receive security over Rangers’ Ibrox Stadium (initial demands for security over Rangers’ Murray Park training complex have been dropped, for reasons as yet unclear). The vehicle for this was to...

Read More

Richard Scudamore vs Dave Boyle: Compare & Contrast

The communications were rude, offensive and ill-thought out. That they were made in an entirely personal capacity offered little or no excuse. A man in his position ought to have the basic judgement not to say such things while being in that position. He did not remain in that position for long. That last sentence tells you, of course, that the above is not about Premier League Chief Executive Richard Scudamore. Not only because Scudamore remains in his position at the time of typing – despite the crude sexism in email correspondence exposed by the Mirror newspaper this weekend. But also because at the time of typing, he is likely to remain in position. No, it was a general view about the then Chief Executive of Supporters Direct (SD), Dave Boyle. On May 21 2011, Boyle was in celebratory mood, as AFC Wimbledon – a flagship example of SD’s work – gained promotion into the Football League, nine years after the very concept of the club was deemed “bad for football.” Via Twitter, he exacted a verbal revenge on two of the main characters in the Wimbledon saga – entrepreneur Pete Winkleman, who moved the old Wimbledon to Milton Keynes, and lawyer Raj Parker, one of the three-man FA panel who approved the move. And Boyle suggested “**** the bible, this is the greatest story ever told.” For reasons...

Read More