Which Way Now For Liverpool?

By on Oct 3, 2010 in English League Football, Finance, Latest | 14 comments

It has now gone far enough to stop even being amusing to the neutral. Supporters of Manchester United and Everton may seek to disagree, but there was something sombre about Liverpool’s home defeat at the hands of Blackpool this afternoon. We are some way from reading the last rites of the club, but there is something in the air at Anfield. That familiar stench of dry rot hangs over the club this evening. The spirit of Liverpool Football Club feels broken. With each passing week, the feeling that this is but a mere blip has receded further and further into the distance and the dread reality for Liverpool supporters, that a season of having to fight the unthinkable fight – the fight to hold onto the club’s place in the Premier League itself – might be looming on the horizon.

There was nowhere else to go this afternoon. There were no excuses and no justifications. Liverpool were beaten by a better team. Blackpool came to Anfield fully aware that this particular beast is wounded at the moment and they had a plan for it. They worked tirelessly, never stopped playing football and there is, ironically, no shame in losing to a team that played as well as they did this afternoon. Their £10,000 per player, per week ceiling on wages is common knowledge. Steven Gerrard alone earns more than the entire Blackpool team, with Fernando Torres not far behind him. It is over-simplistic to get into the debate over players’ wages at the very top end of the Premier League, but some Liverpool supporters could have been forgiven for wondering what exactly their club gets in return for the money that it lavishes on star players.

With their side losing and the game running away from them, the singing for the return of Kenny Dalglish started again. Whether Dalglish, who hasn’t managed for a decade, is the right man for the job is open to question. He is the sentimental choice to replace Roy Hodgson, but sentimental choices often turn out to be bad decisions. Newcastle United repented at leisure for making sentimental choices in bringing Kevin Keegan back to St James Park and then allowing Alan Shearer to oversee their relegation dogfight two seasons ago and if any club offers a template to Liverpool on the subject of how no club is “too big” to be relegated, they are surely it. Yet if Liverpool were to agree with Roy Hodgson that their relationship isn’t working out, he may be not far short of their only choice. At this time of year, few managers that are under contract are likely to want (or be allowed by their clubs) to leave and even if Liverpool do have a greater pull than most other clubs, who would want to go there now, with Liverpool Football Club being in the state that it is in.

Even this speculation pre-supposes that Liverpool are in the market for a new manager. As we mentioned last week, Roy Hodgson in a few weeks into a three year contract at Anfield and will not be cheap to replace. If he decides to dig his heels, he could be difficult to oust. The question of whether he is “out of his depth” is one thing, but it has become abundantly clear that he was the wrong man for this job at this particular time. To suggest that he is suddenly incapable of doing this job doesn’t really make a great deal of sense, but this is something of a straw man argument anyway. The problems at Liverpool are obviously and noticeably about more than the actions of just one man. Where, we could reasonably argue, were the big name players when the chips were down this afternoon? The greater that the clamour for Hodgson’s head becomes, the easier it will be to forget that players that earn tens of thousands of pounds every week have a share in the responsibility for what happens on the pitch.

The manager, then, has lost the goodwill of the supporters, and there seem to be no signs of any improvement in the performance of the players on the pitch over recent weeks. If this sounds like bad news, though, it is nothing in comparison with what the situation at the club could be like after the 6th of October. In a recent article, the Liverpool Echo outlined five possible scenarios for Liverpool FC that could come to pass over the next few weeks or so. One of these involves putting Kop Football (the holding company that owns Liverpool FC) or Kop Football Holdings (which, in turn, owns Kop Football) into administration, but the Echo appears content to state the case this would mean that the club would not be hit with a nine point deduction.

What this comes down to, however, is an interpretation of the rules. In the case of Southampton, for example, when the holding company entered administration the Football League adjudged that the holding company and the football club were effectively one and the same entity and imposed a points deduction anyway. They are under no obligation to, but if the Premier League weren’t to follow the Football League’s example they would stand accused of being complicit in allowing the club to wriggle out of its liabilities without sanction. There is, however, still much more of this story to follow and we will be returning to in greater detail over the next couple of weeks or so.

The boardroom wranglings at Liverpool go part of the way towards telling the story of their atrocious start to the season and, while the venom currently being directed at Roy Hodgson is understandable, it blurs a protest that needs to keep its eye on the ball. Martin O’Neill may be a sensible choice, should a replacement be required in the next few weeks or so, but Kenny Dalglish would be more of a gamble and sacking a new manager would feel like a panic measure. Liverpool are highly unlikely to be relegated this season (unless they were to find themselves in administration and docked nine points), and a new manager wouldn’t have any more access to funds to strengthen the squad. Until the issues surrounding the ownership of the club are resolved, Liverpool’s fortunes seem likely to continue to slide and changing the manager could have unwanted repercussions for them.

Share Button


  1. LFC is dead. Put the body outside and call in the undertakers for God’s sake!


    October 3, 2010

  2. Hodgson has got to go NOW


    October 3, 2010

  3. Honestly I don’t know wats happening anymore,it is do depresing I can’t get my head around it.lets just wait till those two parasites are gone mayb then will get new owners and put this nightmare behind us.I love Liverpool.ynwa 15


    October 3, 2010

  4. People must realise that lfc have been behind for the last 20 years and its been a dramatic downward spiral since the americans came into power. I said nearly 3 years ago that rafa would be sacked and at the same time lfc will struggle on the pitch as well as off in a big way. They would know longer be part of the champs league set up and i honestly believe this will be the case next year also. Lfc actually need nothing short of a miracle to save them. It wont be long before the half decent players actually decide to leave. Only way lfc will be able to attract players is if they give them fantasy football money which is the case now at Man City.

    Either way, LFC will either be a forgotton name or manage to some how turn the corner with a very rich and passion new set of owners. The former looks more realistic mind you.


    October 3, 2010

  5. I saw Roy Hodgson in the car twenty minutes ago. He was doing around
    140mph the wrong way up a one way street with a can of beer in his hand,
    smoking a spliff and beeping his horn. That fucker will do anything to
    get three points nowadays


    October 4, 2010

  6. Good summary of the situation but, despite the hurt that the current form is bringing, it was all too predictable especially for most of us who still had faith in Rafa Benitez. The board got rid of him because he was putting pressure on them to deliver and because (as chairmain Martin Broughton indirectly admitted) sections of the media were highly critical of him. As for the fans who wanted him out because of one bad season, we got a manager who was appointed because of a good one and this is the result of that.

    Worse than the results (which are pretty awful) is the level of performances that have – bar the opening game against Arsenal – been woeful with no direction, shape, purpose or anything resembling Plan B.

    Then there are Hodgson’s comments such as the ones over the weekend where he claimed to be insulted by the suggestions that his tactics couldn’t transfer to a club like Liverpool especially as they had worked at Halmstad and the likes.

    The media portray Roy as a likeable man and that might be the case. However, he also seems to be extremely arrogant with a very inflated opinion of himself, one that is hard to justify given that the best results of his career were two lost UEFA Cup finals.

    So, as you say, getting Dalglish in might not be the right option. But it is becoming increasingly apparent that keeping Hodgson isn’t an option either.


    October 4, 2010

  7. I cannot believe people want Hodgson to go – absolutely crazy. Give the man a chance.

    Liverpool were struggling as a club before he came, and within a couple of months people expect him to have turned it around??

    The rot set in a long time ago, but expectations from a manager that has proved himself before is to turn it around within a couplpe of months? Unbeleivable that anyone could even suggest getting rid of Hodgson now.

    The worst and most foolish thing to do now would be to fire Hodgson. It would make the situation worse.

    Get rid of the people running the club before you ask to get rid of the manager.

    You probably heard it already but Fergie didn’t exactly have a great start at Man U, did he?


    October 4, 2010

  8. Liverpool’s problems go back in some ways much further than the current owners. Over the last 20 years it’s been clear that either a new stadium or a highly unlikely expansion of Anfield was needed to allow the club to compete; the current capacity is 45K and is significantly smaller now than Old Trafford, the Emirates and even St. James Park and Stadium of Light. Plans for the new ground have come and gone, arguments for and against a shared stadium have come and gone, and meanwhile the club has had to limit its ambition partly because it can’t get the extra revenue and interest. The amazing thing in many ways is how Houllier and then Denitez managed to keep winning any trophies at all. Now there’s no Champions League revenue Hodgson has little chance to attract the world-class talent of the past.

    They’re in a vicious circle now; without the stadium they can’t really get the revenue to compete – but they can’t afford the new stadium on their current revenues. It’s very quickly reaching the point of Liverpool having to face being a regular in the battle for a UEFA place at best – and even that assumes the current ownership and debt situation can be resolved.

    Albert Ross

    October 4, 2010

  9. Albert is smack on the money. A decade ago the concept of Liverpool and Everton sharing a ground was unthinkable, now the future for both is unthinkable if they don’t.

    And, sadly, the longer they leave it the smaller it will need to be.

    Mick Nick

    October 4, 2010

  10. Bring Daglish back?!?

    Are Liverpool turning into Newcastle?


    October 5, 2010

  11. It has now gone far enough to stop even being amusing to the neutral.

    Really? I think not. Seeing Liverpool in the relegation zone is hilarious for the neutral.

    Of course the off-the-field process by which they come to be there is grotesque, but the actual fact of their presence in that territory is very funny indeed.


    October 5, 2010

  12. What Liverpool need is a manager who has big club pedigree. Someone better suited to Real Madrid than Fulham.

    Step forward Big Sam Allardyce.


    October 6, 2010


  1. Which Way Now For Liverpool? « Scissors Kick - [...] Which Way Now For Liverpool? “It has now gone far enough to stop even being amusing to the neutral. …
  2. The Premier League First Eleven « Twohundredpercent - [...] Monday, Ian King wrote on this very site that Liverpool’s current problems had “gone far enough to stop even …

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>