Match Of The Week: Spurs 9-1 Wigan Athletic

9 By Ian  |   The Ball  |   November 22, 2009  |     12

One of the more curious aspects of the game of football is the narrow range of scores that turn up in professional matches. Teams will often score five goal in a match a couple of times over the course of a season, and they will usually concede the same number in one match. How come, then, that we only get to see a 5-5 draw once in a blue moon? It’s the same with absolute, complete and utter thrashings. A Football League side will run up double figures against a side in the same league as them every once in a while, but some clubs have never done it.

At Sunday League level, this is seldom a consideration. Matches finish with a variety of scores that boggle the mind, which would seem to indicate that better teams find it more difficult to score goals and worse teams find it more difficult to defend. Every once in a while, though, two professional teams meet and reality is suspended. One of the teams suffers a complete defensive collapse, the other hits top form, and the final scoreline ends up resembling something that you might expect to see on a park pitch. More often than the not, the match itself is simply a freak and doesn’t give much away about the fortunes of either of the clubs concerned.

So it was at White Hart Lane this afternoon. Tottenham Hotspur harbour ambitions of breaking into the Champions League four, but their performances against Manchester United and Arsenal didn’t particularly seem to indicate that this is likely to happen this season. Wigan Athletic, meanwhile, started excellently with a win at Aston Villa on the opening day of the season and also beat Chelsea at home, but have showed considerable defensive vunerabilities before this season, including a 4-1 defeat at Blackpool in the League Cup, a 5-0 home defeat at the hands of Manchester United and a 4-0 defeat at Portsmouth. There wasn’t, however, much in the form book to predict what would come to pass in the second half of this match.

And it was the second half in the case of this particular match. Spurs started this match very strongly and took an early lead through Peter Crouch’s close range header, but Wigan had occasional attacking flourishes throughout the rest of the half. Jason Scotland pulled a smart save out of Heurelho Gomes and Charles N’Zogbia grazed the frame of the goal with a curling shot from edge of the penalty area. It probably wouldn’t have been an accurate summary of the events of the first half – Spurs spent much of the first thirty minutes more or less camped in their half – but, as difficult as it may seem to believe now, Wigan could have got to the half-time break on level terms.

Spurs had far the better of the first half, but no-one was properly prepared for what was to follow. Two quick goals from Jermaine Defoe in the first nine minutes of the half put the match beyond any reasonable doubt although it looked as if there might be a degree of controversy when the ball appeared to strike Paul Scharner’s arm as he controlled it to pull a goal back for Wigan, but this was a temporary respite for the visitors and within sixty seconds Defoe had a hat-trick and Spurs’ three goal lead was restored.

From here on, the floodgates opened as the Wigan defence laid itself on an altar for Tottenham to tear them to pieces. Aaron Lennon added the fifth, Defoe the sixth and seventh. By the dying seconds, every bit of luck that could be going Tottenham’s way was going Tottenham’s way. With two minutes left to play, David Bentley’s free-kick hit the crossbar, bounced back, hit Chris Kirkland and bounced in. In injury time Niko Kranjcar curled one into the top corner from outside the penalty area to complete the rout. They’ve scored nine goals on “Match Of The Day” before, have Spurs – in 1977 they beat Bristol Rovers 9-0 in front of the BBC cameras in the Second Division – but this result is something else altogether.

Is this the beginning of a bright new era for Tottenham Hotspur? Tempting though it may be to say that this time they might be able to crack the top four, whether they actually can do this or not may end up coming down to matters that are beyond their control. Their losses to Manchester United and Arsenal seemed to indicate that the gap between them and the top of the table is still too great to launch anything like a challenge for the Premier League title (but no-one was seriously suggesting that, were they?), but Liverpool continue to stutter, Aston Villa and Everton still dont look as strong as they did last season and Manchester City’s team hasn’t yet arrived at being the sum of its parts.

Moreover, a win of this margin brings another advantage to Spurs – they now have a better goal difference than fifth placed Aston Villa – and, in a broader sense, with Arsenal losing, Liverpool and Manchester City cancelling each other out and Aston Villa failing to win at Burnley, results elsewhere also went their way. It remains to soon to be able to say that Spurs will be able to carry a top four position through to the end of the season, but their position is considerably stronger than it was at the start of the season.

What, though, went wrong for Wigan? It would be harsh to blame their goalkeeper, Chris Kirkland. He made a string of excellent saves and deserved better than the free-kick that bounced in off him. Wigan have given the impression of being capable of defensive implosion before this season, though, and this is what seems to have happened in excelsis this afternoon. After the fourth Tottenham goal, it was simply too easy for the home side. Although every pass seemed to be crisp and picked out to perfection, Wigan heads dropped alarmingly after the match went beyond them and the gaps across their back line were obvious and plentiful enough for Defoe pick and then telegraph where he wanted the passes to go to.

The muttering of Wigan supporters has begun, and this is not particularly surprising. Their performance in the second half this afternoon was worrying because of the way that they folded, and fixing morale is a major test for manager Roberto Martinez, presuming that Dave Whelan doesn’t get an itchy trigger finger and arrive at the conclusion that he can’t afford any more of this sort of thing. If he does, Martinez could soon find himself scanning the “Situations Vacant” columns in the newspapers sooner rather than later. Wigan supporters will find out a lot about the mettle of their team from their next two matches against Sunderland and Birmingham City. It is critical that they pick themselves up, dust themselves down and put the events of this afternoon behind them. If they don’t, a slide towards the relegation zone at the bottom of the table over the next few weeks seems more likely than not.



Ian began writing Twohundredpercent in May 2006. He lives in Brighton. He has also written for, amongst others, Pitch Invasion, FC Business Magazine, The Score, When Saturday Comes, Stand Against Modern Football and The Football Supporter. Ian was the first winner of the Socrates Award For Not Being Dead Yet at the 2010 NOPA awards for football bloggers.

  • November 23, 2009 at 1:12 am


    I enjoyed this performance.
    I also believe that Tottenham stuttered against Man U, Arsenal and Stoke due to the loss of three good players, one of who has yet to return to full fitness. I believe they will get even better when Modric returns and Harry adds a tough midfielder in January.

  • November 23, 2009 at 9:13 am


    I agree with the above comments and it’s beyond doubt that they generally provide excellent entertainment, win, draw or lose. Saw my first match at the Lane in September 1957, a 5-3 defeat to Portsmouth, followed by a 3-3 draw against Newcastle at Christmas and rounded off by a 6-2 win against Villa the following March. It’s no wonder I’ve followed them ever since!

  • November 23, 2009 at 9:18 am

    Gervillian Swike

    In an interview after the match, the only person Dave Whelan blamed for Wigan’s poor performances this season was Steve Bruce, blaming Martinez “not one iota” and going on to say that Steve Bruce made a lot of “dodgy signings” that Martinez is now stuck with. Now that’s loyalty. Blind, stupid loyalty, self-preserving loyalty, loyalty that goes beyond all realms of credibility, but loyalty all the same. He’s a very good coach Martinez, and will recover from this result, although he must surely be wondering if he’s as good as he obviously thought he was, given the serious tunings that have come Wigan’s way this season. And Steve Bruce? Well, I’m sure he’ll welcome a chance to pit his wits against his dodgy signings in the next game.

  • November 23, 2009 at 9:43 am

    Michael Wood

    “(Spurs) will get even better when Modric returns and Harry adds a tough midfielder in January.”

    It is telling that Harry not only has Tom Huddlestone who fills that role perfectly but is – if rumours are to be believed – going to go buy another quality player to throw on the pile at White Hart Lane which – if I were a Spurs fan – I would find troubling.

    Harry has a track record of overspending clubs into trouble and the fact that he left Portsmouth in a huge mess after his much touted best ever season to join Spurs would be worrying for me. He used Fratton Park as a springboard to Spurs and didn’t care if the board broke behind him.

    Now of course Spurs fans would say that there is no where to spring from from White Hart Lane but consider this. If England go out of the World Cup first round and Fabio is moved on how enhanced is Harry’s CV by a top four finish? If the difference between that and fifth is a couple of players who Spurs can’t really afford will Harry make those signings or keep his chequebook in his pocket?

    The Portsmouth experience suggests he spends and damns the future.

  • November 23, 2009 at 11:51 am


    “Harry has a track record of overspending clubs into trouble’

    No manager overspends on his own. The money is sanction by the Chairman and his board.
    I think you are misjudging Levy if you believe this will happen at Spurs.

  • November 23, 2009 at 5:01 pm

    Michael Wood

    Perhaps I am misjudging Levy and perhaps I’m misjudging Harry but I’m not sure I can see the meeting at White Hart Lane where Handsome Harry comes out to tell the media that they have been having a chat and decided not to spend the money and that he is totally happy with that and if it comes down to Levy vs Redknapp over £20m and wages for a good but not great player who could catapult Spurs in the top five the chairman will need a lot of gumption to stand up to the manager who will have the fans on his side.

    As I say. Spurs fans be cautious and hope that all at the club do the same.

  • November 23, 2009 at 5:41 pm


    The point I was making Michael is that any manager will spend the money that is allocated to him for transfer fees so it’s important that the Chairman gives the manager a budget which clearly didn’t occur at Fratton Park in Harry’s rein otherwise they wouldn’t be in the financial pickle they are now.

    You obviously didn’t see the latest excellent profit figures for THFC Plc and this is after all their transfer dealings and purchasing large areas surrounding White Hart Lane in readiness for the construction of their near 60,000 capacity new stadium.

  • November 24, 2009 at 1:21 pm

    Michael Wood

    Your points are good Paul and they are true in most cases (and hopefully this case) but I saw eight years of great profit figures at Valley Parade before the one that had a red £33m figure on it and so I am acutely aware of the fact that all figures are retroactive and show where a club has been, not where it is going.

    That said hopefully it is going only good places and that Daniel Levy will be able to set the budget for Harry Redknapp and that Redknapp will be happy to work within those budgets. The worry is that Levy will tell Harry there is £Xm in the bank 75% of which is there for players and that Harry will reply that he wants more of that. One hopes that Levy will be more canny than the people at Portsmouth who were not able to see anything other than short/medium term success and are having problems in the longer term.

    If Levy is able to stay strong in the face of – for example – a request from Harry in a month that he adds to a central midfield of Wilson Palacios, Luka Modrić, Niko Kranjčar, Jermaine Jenas and Tom Huddlestone and tell the manager that he does not need an extra player then Spurs would not follow the same path as Portsmouth.

  • November 25, 2009 at 1:16 pm


    I notice that Robbie Keane has not demanded a replay in light of paul Scharner’s handball before scoring Wigans goal 😉

Leave A Comment

Also available on…
Socialise With Us