The BBC Is Wrong To Consider Slashing Its Local Sports Coverage

9 By Ian  |   The Ball  |   October 8, 2011  |     13

One of the more pleasing aspects of modern life is the plurality of media that is presented to us. The internet has given us a plethora of options for reading, watching and listening that would have been unimaginable twenty years ago, and we should be grateful for the fact that, no matter what our particular inclinations might be, whether serious or irreverent, whether demanding fact or fantasy, we will usually be able to find it, if we look hard enough. One example of how what might have been treated as an afterthought but has instead flourished into essential weekly listening for thousands is BBC London’s Non-League Show.

In the past, the show would have been tucked away in a quiet corner of the BBC’s local schedules, available only to those that live in the London area, but this particular show has blossomed thanks to canny usage of social media, with a downloadable version available to everybody and a place on the BBC’s Iplayer service which ensures that people that wish to hear it can do at any time. Now, however, cuts at the BBC are threatening its existence, as well as a broader range of local sport, and we should, perhaps, take a moment to pause and consider whether the BBC is acting rashly in cutting a local service that simply will not be replaced by commercial alternatives.

Those that listen to the programme will be fully aware of the important position that it holds within the non-league game. Host Caroline Barker and an array of guests including the Harrow Borough manager Dave Anderson (whose withering put-down of one of the attempts to buy Wrexham Football Club earlier this year was as damning an indictment of those that were seeking to take control of the club as we could have hoped to hear) have shaped the programme into a nationwide experience which isn’t afraid to dip its toe into the frequently murky waters of the financial affairs of non-league clubs. As such it has, over the last couple of years, become something of a rallying point for the whole of the non-league game and, if there is such a thing as a “non-league community”, to lose it would leave a gaping hole at the heart of this community.

It isn’t only this show that may be facing the axe as a result of the “Public Consultation – Section 4″ of the BBC’s “Delivering Quality First” report. The reason why the programme is now in danger is a radical slimming down of the corporation’s regional sports broadcasting. In the case of London the consultation papers state (and it is somewhat difficult to read this without imagining a degree of relish in the tone of it) that, “BBC London would lose a number of off-peak programmes and reduce other spend to bring the station more in line with other BBC Local Radio stations”. It isn’t only the Non-League Show that may be facing the axe, too. The BBC’s local radio stations provide an invaluable service in their coverage of matches at a lower level and it seems likely that, from the end of this season, they will also be facing substantial cuts.

Of course, there is a debate to be had on the subject of how the BBC spends its money, when we consider that it is, ultimately, largely funded by the taxpayer through the television licence. In this case, however, what is striking is that the corporation is moving towards putting commercial imperatives before anything else. If we are to retain a national broadcaster in the twenty-first century, the truth of the matter is that is that this sort of diverse coverage, which doesn’t necessarily have a high commercial value, is exactly the sort of programming that the BBC should be producing. The BBC’s policy statement on the subject mentions “our ambition to increase the distinctiveness of BBC services and serve all audiences, but it seems that those that wish to avail themselves of local sports coverage in the evening are not included in this grouping.

To argue this point isn’t to offer an opinion on the Non-League Show’s quality, or to offer a critique on the local radio coverage that BBC Local radio offers. To put it another way, the question of whether the local sports coverage that the BBC currently produces isn’t a matter of personal preference. The point is that part of the BBC’s remit should be to cover areas that commercial broadcasters won’t see any value in, but still serve a target audience. Nobody is going to step in and replace the BBC’s coverage of the non-league game, and once it has gone it will be much-missed by many. As a publicly accountable body, though, the plans are still at the consultation stage and at the bottom of this page you have the opportunity to comment on the moves that have been proposed.

The BBC still holds considerable public support, and it is this support that keeps the licence fee in place. When the corporation itself starts to make decisions that will strip away the very heart of what makes it different to commercial broadcasters, though, defending the licence fee becomes considerably more difficult. Non-league football isn’t a massive community, but is a sizeable one and it will be left considerably poorer for the loss of the coverage that the BBC offers at present. If the BBC is to continue to receive public funding, it should stick to what differentiates it from other broadcasters. Those that are opposed to the licence fee will not stop their opposition to it because of these cuts, and the BBC will be poorer for the loss of this coverage. There is, however, still time for them to reconsider and those of us should be applying pressure to ensure that they do.

You can follow Twohundredpercent on Twitter here.



Ian began writing Twohundredpercent in May 2006. He lives in Brighton. He has also written for, amongst others, Pitch Invasion, FC Business Magazine, The Score, When Saturday Comes, Stand Against Modern Football and The Football Supporter. Ian was the first winner of the Socrates Award For Not Being Dead Yet at the 2010 NOPA awards for football bloggers.

  • October 8, 2011 at 4:52 pm


    It is an excellent programme.

    Put it on 5 Live, problem solved.

  • October 8, 2011 at 8:13 pm

    Johnny Too Bad

    5 Live is way too Premiersh!t centric, driven, as it is, by it’s adoration of celeb culture. Local radio gives invaluable coverage to lower and non-league clubs. Sack that Derbyshire woman and Nicky Campbell, spend the money on local BBC radio sports coverage!

  • October 9, 2011 at 6:39 am

    Tim Vickerman

    It is an absolute shame to see the BBC, bullied by the Murdochs and Tories, bowing to commercial pressure to consider axeing the very things (6 Music, Asian Network, BBC 4) that separate it from the mainstream dross.

    As for 5 Live, the Football Daily was wall-to-wall Tevez last week, even at the expense of reporting the actual, you know, football.

    I seem to recall in the late 90s they used to do features and radio documentaries and had the Football Forum – an excellent programme that was broadcast monthly from various regions and had good representation from ex-players, managers and supporters of ALL clubs in the region, Premier League down to Non-League. Whatever happened to that?

    One plus point has been the new Monday Night Club: Rebooted where they give about half an hour over to online journalists who actually shed some insight onto a broader range of topics than the top of the Premier League. But I suppose this won’t draw the listeners Robbie Savage does and will soon be axed.

  • October 9, 2011 at 2:22 pm

    Barry Gill

    Radio Leeds, who used to do a wonderful local cricket show on a saturday evening, cut backs, what cut backs? Recent match between Huddersfield Town & Bradford City had two sets of commentators and summarisers on different wavelengths….

  • October 9, 2011 at 2:31 pm


    At present it is quite conceivable for six different reporting teams to be covering a single match – Final Score reporter, Match of the Day / Football League Show commentator, 5 live, commentators from local radio from both teams local areas and someone sat in an office doing a toe-curlingly awful text commentary. With a bit more thought there are obvious avenues to save money in these circumstances and plough it into the true public service area of the Non League Show.

  • October 9, 2011 at 7:37 pm

    Save County Cricket From BBC Axe | Don't Chase The Wide Ones

    […] are a few others who feel the same way: Silly-pointless, Twohundredpercent, Play For Country Not For Self, The Short […]

  • October 10, 2011 at 11:13 am

    Ted Blair

    The only time the BBC give a damn is when a non-league team gets to play a “big” team in the FA Cup – an opportunity for them to wheel out that old fool Motson so he can rabbit on about Ronnie Radford…

  • October 12, 2011 at 8:59 pm


    The cutbacks on sports coverage will be driven by cutbacks on local services. Unfortunately the BBC have decided to centralise their radio and TV coverage, a move that will reduce local sports coverage outside of the Premiership to the brief and shallow qualities of The Football League Show.

  • November 16, 2011 at 10:17 am

    Raith Supporters Trust » Blog Archive » News Round-Up from SD – 28/10/11

    […] The BBC is wrong to consider slashing its local sports coverage Twohundredpercent […]

Leave A Comment

Also available on…
Socialise With Us