As Stephen Vaughan Goes To Prison: Chester FC, One Year On

5 By Ian  |   The Ball  |   March 16, 2011  |     41

Revenge, it is said, is a dish best served cold and, while the imprisonment of Stephen Vaughan for fifteen months at the North Liverpool Community Justice Centre yesterday was an incident unrelated to his involvement in football, there may be some people in Chester that will regard this sentence as some degree of providence, held over for what he did to their club. Vaughan was imprisoned for punching a  police officer after an incident outside his house, following an incident at a pub on the Wirral. The judge, David Fletcher CBE, said of Vaughan’s behaviour that it was, “It was extremely unattractive. It involved a police officer making a perfectly legitimate inquiry.” His son, along with another man, was given a six month community order and 120 hours unpaid work after admitting threatening behaviour.

That this news should emerge on this of all weeks is particularly striking, as it was almost exactly a year to a day since the final act of Vaughan’s failure as the owner of Chester City FC was played out at the High Court in London. On the 10th of March 2010, with no-one even there to try and defend the club’s honour, Chester City, who had already been expelled from the Football Conference, were wound up. It was a moment to pause and reflect on what had happened there over the previous few months, but it was a moment to pause only, because the club’s supporters trust, City Fans United, had considerably more important work to do. They had to get on with the job of rebuilding football in the city of Chester.

First came a battle to secure the lease to the council-owned Deva Stadium. With the benefit of hindsight, we can see that there was surely no question that the club would secure this lease, but with a rival bid to see off from Denmark nothing could be taken for granted until Cheshire West & Chester Council had made their final decision on the matter. It took until the start of May for a final decision from the council, and it was the news that all of their supporters had been hoping for. Chester FC – the newly-formed club founded by those who knew that Chester City had to die in order for football to be reborn in the city – would start their first season playing at The Deva Stadium.

The club was initially placed in the North-West Counties League but, after an appeal to the FA, this was amended so that they could start this season in Division One North of the Evostik League. It should be said that, in the dying months of Chester City, nobody was quite certain whether too many bridges had been burned and too much bad blood had been spilt for the club to be able to be reborn. The question of whether Chester FC could rebuild its links with its local community, which had all but been severed under the years of Vaughan’s ownership of the club, was a very real one. The sense of energy that came from the trust board of the new club, however, felt energising, even for those of us on the outside looking in.

The first answer to the question of whether this new club could succeed under the supporters trust model of ownership came with their first home league match in the Evostik League at the start of September. City’s average attendance during their last season in the Football League had dipped below 2,000 and crowds in the Football Conference – with a boycott eventually in place – slumped even further, to around 1,100. What sort of support might they attract in the eighth tier of English football, as far from the Blue Square Premier as, say, Accrington Stanley are from the Premier League? The answer was surprising, even to those that had been sanguine about their prospects. On a Wednesday evening at the start of September, 2,734 people turned out to welcome Chester FC into the Evostik League agains Trafford. They won the match by six goals to nil.

Since then, the club has gone from strength to strength. What initially looked as if it might be a tight race for the Evostik League Division One North championship has turned into a procession – they currently sit twelve points clear at the top of the table and haven’t lost in the league since the 11th of December – and home crowds have held steady at an average of 2,377, a number that seems certain to rise by the end of this season as the title run-in approaches. The supporters even have their first hero in the form of striker Michael Wilde, who has already scored twenty-nine goals this season. The team could, of course, yet fail to win the league this season – nobody at the club will be counting their chickens until the title is mathematically theirs – and, the road back to the Blue Square Premier or even, dare we say it, the Football League will get increasingly difficult as they progress, but there has been little to suggest this season that, either on or off the pitch, Chester FC won’t be capable of reclaiming their previous stature within the time-scales that the club has set itself.

With a five year plan to make the Blue Square Premier, Chester FC are further proof of the fact that while the idea of supporters ownership is by no means a panacea for all that is wrong in British football, it remains a more than workable option that has, in the case of this club, given a whole city something to be proud of. During the tail-end of his time in charge of the club, Stephen Vaughan was more than prone to slating City Fans United and those that chose to follow them. As he embarks upon his spell at Her Majesty’s Pleasure, he may choose to reflect upon the new club’s attendance figures for this season, their place at the top of the league and that the club that died on his watch has been reborn as something happily unrecognisable from the wreck that it became under his ownership. To borrow a phrase from Supporters Direct’s Dave Boyle, made during a speech at FC United of Manchester’s “Beyond The Debt” rally, which was held as Chester City were expiring: “For as long as people within football continue to underestimate football supporters, the supporters will continue to score victories over them”.

Chester FC’s year was documented by a visit from the BBC’s “Football Focus” last weekend. You can see their report here:

Follow Twohundredpercent on Twitter here.



Ian began writing Twohundredpercent in May 2006. He lives in Brighton. He has also written for, amongst others, Pitch Invasion, FC Business Magazine, The Score, When Saturday Comes, Stand Against Modern Football and The Football Supporter. Ian was the first winner of the Socrates Award For Not Being Dead Yet at the 2010 NOPA awards for football bloggers.

  • March 18, 2011 at 3:20 pm

    Chester on football focus today - Page 2 - - Wrexham

    […] any link to the feature online? I'd be interested to watch it. It can be found at the bottom of this article. […]

  • March 25, 2011 at 7:04 pm

    Raith Supporters Trust » Blog Archive » News Round-Up from SD – 25/03/11

    […] As Stephen Vaughan Goes To Prison: Chester FC, One Year On Two Hundred Percent […]

  • June 3, 2011 at 6:25 am

    Supporters Trusts: Case Studies - Page 13 - - Wrexham

    […] Re: Supporters Trusts: Case Studies I hope I'm not insulting any of you lot by posting this story about Chester – for obvious reasons it might wind some of you up, which is not my intention. It's also likely that given the close proximity, you already know this story well. However if any of you haven't seen the Football Focus video about the Trust model there, I think it's worth taking a look at. It gives a good idea of the way that supporter ownership at small clubs can have a galvanising effect and in itself can give a club an all-round boost. In addition, it illustrates what I meant when I talked about the "vibe" of a supporter owned club. Anyway, I'll probably get a ban for this! It was nice knowing you. (Scroll down for the video at the bottom) As Stephen Vaughan Goes To Prison: Chester FC, One Year On Twohundredpercent […]

  • August 19, 2011 at 9:58 pm

    SW19 Womble

    Proof if proof needed that fans starting and running a football club is a piece of p1ss.

  • August 19, 2011 at 10:00 pm

    SW19 Womble

    PS bye bye Vaughan you fcuking criminal

Leave A Comment

Also available on…
Speek Yo Branes
Socialise With Us